DIY vs Delegated Job Search: A Cost-Benefit Analysis
    Blog

    DIY vs Delegated Job Search: A Cost-Benefit Analysis

    Author

    Shabuddin MS

    Looking for a job? Here's a quick comparison of doing it yourself (DIY) vs getting help:

    Factor DIY Job Search Delegated Job Search
    Cost Cheaper upfront 15-18% of first year's salary
    Time 30-45 hours per job 20-30 hours per job
    Control You're in charge Experts handle it
    Job Access Public listings only Hidden jobs too
    Success Rate 5 out of 250 get an interview Potentially higher

    Key points:

    • DIY is cheaper but takes more time
    • Delegating costs more but saves time and gives access to hidden jobs
    • Average job search takes 5 months
    • Only 2% of applicants typically get interviewed
    • Networking has a 50% success rate vs 2-4% from job boards

    Bottom line: Your choice depends on your budget, time, and career goals. DIY works if you have time and a tight budget. Delegating might be smart if you're short on time or aiming high.

    1. Doing It Yourself

    Managing your own job search? It's tough, but it can pay off. Here's what you need to know:

    Money Required

    A DIY job search isn't free. Here's where you might spend:

    • Resume and cover letter help
    • LinkedIn Premium (if you want it)
    • Classes to boost your skills

    Pro Tip: Save those receipts! Job search expenses might be tax-deductible.

    Time Spent

    Job searching is time-consuming. Here's a quick breakdown:

    Job Seeker Status Daily Time
    Unemployed 5-8 hours
    Employed 1-2 hours
    Recent Grads 3-5 hours

    Make your time count:

    • Set daily goals
    • Use a calendar or to-do list
    • Focus on quality applications

    Success Chances

    Let's be real: DIY job searching is tough. The numbers:

    • Only 5 out of 250 applicants usually get an interview
    • 75% of resumes get rejected by ATS before a human sees them
    • 85% of jobs are filled through networking

    Want to boost your odds? Try this:

    1. Tailor your resume with keywords from the job description
    2. Network like crazy on LinkedIn
    3. Apply ASAP - top candidates often get hired within 10 days
    "Most job seekers do essentially the same things, even when they think they are job searching differently." - Phil, National Recruiter and Career Coach

    Phil's right. So, how do you stand out?

    • A pro resume can boost your earning potential by 7%
    • 54% of employers have rejected candidates based on social media

    Here's the kicker: The average job search takes 5 months. If you're replacing a $50K salary, you could lose over $40K in income and benefits. For a $100K salary? That jumps to $80K.

    2. Getting Help from Experts

    Tired of job hunting alone? Let's talk about getting help from job search experts. It's not free, but it might be worth it.

    Money Required

    Professional help costs money. Here's what you might pay:

    Service Cost Range What You Might Get
    Career Coaching $100-$500 per hour 10-25% more money in 1-2 years
    Resume Writing $100-$1000 Better chance with ATS and quick resume reviews
    Recruitment Agency 15-18% of first year's salary Hidden jobs, faster hiring

    Want to save cash? Try group coaching ($100-$150 per person) or webinars ($50 per session).

    Time Spent

    Hiring help can save you time:

    Resume writers can get you a polished resume in 3-5 days. Recruiters handle most of the application process. Career coaches usually offer 4-12 month packages with sessions every two weeks or month.

    "Good recruiters or headhunters can help businesses find more talent, save time and money, and offer industry expertise. They make hiring easier and can keep things private." - American Staffing Association

    Success Chances

    No guarantees, but getting help can boost your odds:

    Indeed has over 150 million resumes and adds 10 new jobs every second worldwide. LinkedIn lets employers find good candidates even if they haven't applied. Glassdoor gives you the inside scoop on company culture and interviews.

    Some services, like scale.jobs, have virtual assistants apply to jobs for you. They make custom resumes and cover letters, so you can focus on networking and getting ready for interviews.

    sbb-itb-564272e

    What Works and What Doesn't

    Job searching can be a DIY project or a task you delegate. Both have their pros and cons. Let's break it down:

    Aspect DIY Job Search Delegated Job Search
    Cost Cheaper upfront Pricier (15-18% of first year's salary)
    Time 30-45 hours per job 20-30 hours per job
    Control You're the boss You're not the boss
    Job Access Public listings only Hidden jobs too
    Personalization It's all you Some customization
    Success Rate 5 out of 250 get an interview Might be higher

    DIY Job Search: The Good and The Bad

    What's good? It's cheap, it's personal, and you'll learn a ton. You're in charge, so you can tailor each application to show off your best self.

    What's not so good? It's a time sink. The average job search takes 5 months. That's a lot of Netflix you're missing out on. Plus, you might not see all the jobs out there. Oh, and those pesky Applicant Tracking Systems? They reject 75% of resumes before a human even sees them.

    Delegated Job Search: The Ups and The Downs

    The ups? It's a time-saver. You've got pros in your corner, giving you the inside scoop. And they've got access to jobs you can't see.

    The downs? It'll cost you. We're talking 15-18% of your first year's salary. Ouch. You're also not in the driver's seat anymore. And sometimes, recruiters might not get you or the company culture you're after.

    "Good recruiters or headhunters can help businesses find more talent, save time and money, and offer industry expertise. They make hiring easier and can keep things private." - American Staffing Association

    So, which is better? It depends on you. Your wallet, your clock, and what you want. Think about it, then make your move.

    Conclusion

    DIY and delegated job searches both have their place. Your choice depends on your situation, resources, and goals.

    Here's a quick comparison:

    Factor DIY Job Search Delegated Job Search
    Cost Lower upfront Higher initial
    Time More consuming Saves time
    Control Full Less direct
    Job Access Public listings Hidden opportunities
    Personalization High Some

    Tight budget and lots of time? DIY might be your best bet. You'll learn skills and keep control. But remember: the average job search takes about 5 months. That's a lot of lost income if you're unemployed.

    Short on time or aiming high? Delegating could be smart. Services like scale.jobs can save you time with virtual assistants applying for you. They'll even create custom resumes and cover letters. This frees you up for networking and interview prep.

    When deciding, think about:

    1. Your finances: Can you afford help?
    2. Your schedule: How much time can you spend job hunting?
    3. Your industry: Some fields benefit more from recruiter connections.
    4. Your career level: Executive jobs often need a targeted approach.
    5. Free tools: Use LinkedIn and Glassdoor, no matter what.

    There's no perfect solution. You might even mix and match, using some pro services while keeping control of other parts.

    Whatever you choose, stay focused and open to opportunities. Your next big career move is out there. You just need the right strategy to find it.

    FAQs

    What is the success rate of applying for jobs?

    Landing a job isn't easy. The numbers paint a pretty tough picture:

    • Only 1 in 4 resumes make it past initial screening
    • You'll need to send out about 27 applications for 1 interview
    • Just 2% of applicants get interviewed
    • Companies typically interview 6 people for each job

    So, your odds of getting hired from a single application? Pretty slim. But don't worry, there are ways to boost your chances:

    Strategy How it helps
    Tailor your resume Gets you past those pesky ATS systems
    Network 50% success rate (way better than the 2-4% from job boards)
    Use a pro service Can make your applications shine

    Here's the thing: job hunting takes time. On average, it's about 4 months from start to finish. During that time, most people:

    • Tweak their resume 4 times
    • Write 4 cover letters
    • Send out 7 applications
    • Go through 5 interviews

    Want to up your game? Mix DIY efforts with some pro help. For example, scale.jobs offers virtual assistants to handle applications. This frees you up to focus on networking and prepping for interviews.

    Land Jobs Faster and Easier with

    Your Assistant applies to jobs on your behalf with Custom Resumes and Cover Letters making your job search 5x faster with less stress and zero grunt work.

    Job Search Assistant 1Job Search Assistant 2Job Search Assistant 3

    Our assistants save you 100+ hours of grunt work.

    Less than 2% of applications receive interview calls. Spend your time and effort wisely.

    demo
    TechstarsCMU_CFE
    YourstoryForbesDNAFinancial_Express
    • Facebook
    • CMU
    • instakart
    • lyft
    • nyu
    • su
    • um
    • dd
    • tesla
    • meta
    • duke

    Hear what our customers have to say about their experience with Scale.jobs

    PayPal
    Aubrey Smith

    Aubrey Smith

    Software Engineer

    "As I work full time and couldn't spare much time for applying jobs. Applying each job is such a painful process sometimes it takes more than 15 minutes for one application. I got tired and demotivated after a week of applying by myself. I heard of 'Scale.jobs' where they apply for your jobs online. Team did a great help in applying jobs and always available to talk. They followed my priority in applying jobs as well."

    via Trustpilot
    Priceline
    Teja Aditya Surabhi

    Teja Aditya Surabhi

    Product Strategy & Growth

    "I moved from India to Canada and recruiting worked very differently from where I was coming. It took me a while to get a hang of how job search works here and applying to jobs was my biggest pain point. It felt pointless and right then, I found scale.jobs that helped me focus on the right things. In fact, I was able to build a small micro-service FIREmails.xyz from the time I saved."

    via Trustpilot
    JP Morgan Chase
    Apoorv Singh

    Apoorv Singh

    Consultant

    "Facing a layoff during a recession with only 60 days left on my H1B visa, I was in a critical situation. I took their premium service and went all in aggressively. 4 weeks down the line, I secured three job offers, with a 75% salary increase compared to my previous position. Their professionalism and efficiency were exceptional. I am grateful for their support during this crucial time. Highly recommend Scale.jobs and it exceeded all my expectations."

    via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Such a great service!

      Such a great initiative and service! Applying jobs everyday has been super daunting. But now with scale jobs, one can apply 100s of jobs per day as well as focus on prep for interviews.

      Sona Tambe • Apr 15, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      I've had an exceptional experience

      I've had an exceptional experience with the Scale Jobs team, and I can't recommend them highly enough. From the outset, their dedication and enthusiasm were palpable, making a significant...

      Sajia Nikita • April 01, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great experience, Reliable Team, Highly Recommended

      I have had a great experience with the scale.jobs team. The associate assigned for me is trustworthy and sincere in their approach. I would recommend trying out scale.jobs to anyone looking to make more time in their schedule for interview prep and networking, so that the repetitive portion of job application process can be outsourced. I personally feel it's good value for money. Would recommend setting up a call with their team if you're doubtful about whether or not the product will be useful for you. They are a really honest bunch of folks and I appreciate it so much.

      Anuva Agarwal • May 18, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Really good with applying jobs

      I think they provide good assistance to apply jobs and I did get some positive responses after that. hence, I am quite satisfied with the experience of scale.jobs. There cover letters....

      Neha Sawant • March 21, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Superb service!

      Great team of people and the person that was assigned to work with me was wonderful too. Majority of the heavy lifting is done by them and they are in constant communication with you....

      Adnan Lakdawala • July 01, 2023
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Drastically reducing the burden!

      Apply at scale has immensely helped me with my tedious job application process. Their team is proactive and smart. Once they understand your profile, they are good at applying.......

      Mihika Srivastava • December 01, 2023
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      They took away the work I was slacking…

      They took away the work I was slacking on, which allowed me to relax and not worry about submitting my applications. I was on an extremely busy schedule.

      Harish Reddy Kondapalli • January 29, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great for international students

      Scale.jobs has been an excellent help in applying for high volume of jobs which otherwise would be very time consuming. This is extremely useful in the current job market as a high-volume approach helped me get few interview calls which I wasn't getting earlier. Also, they keep bringing in new features such as the networking tool. Excited to try it out!

      Shobhit Datta • May 31, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great service to save time while interviewing

      Great service to save time while interviewing. I have been using it for a week. The support is nice and turnaround is within 24 hours. Price point maybe on the expensive side, but you pay for the time it saves to create accounts on several sites and apply jobs.

      Hemil P • May 20, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      extremely helpful in this challenging…

      I've been using Scale.jobs, and it has been an incredibly useful tool for my job search. The platform's intuitive design and user-friendly interface make it easy to navigate through various job listings. I appreciate the detailed job descriptions and the ability to filter positions based on my preferences. The application process is streamlined, saving me a lot of time. Overall, Scale.jobs has significantly enhanced my job search experience, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for new opportunities.

      Avinash Amudala • May 28, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Good service to save some time from job applications

      So far, my experience has been positive. I have been using their service for 2 months and am looking forward to continuing.

      Hari Vilas • May 19, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Such a great service!

      Such a great initiative and service! Applying jobs everyday has been super daunting. But now with scale jobs, one can apply 100s of jobs per day as well as focus on prep for interviews.

      Sona Tambe • Apr 15, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      I've had an exceptional experience

      I've had an exceptional experience with the Scale Jobs team, and I can't recommend them highly enough. From the outset, their dedication and enthusiasm were palpable, making a significant...

      Sajia Nikita • April 01, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great experience, Reliable Team, Highly Recommended

      I have had a great experience with the scale.jobs team. The associate assigned for me is trustworthy and sincere in their approach. I would recommend trying out scale.jobs to anyone looking to make more time in their schedule for interview prep and networking, so that the repetitive portion of job application process can be outsourced. I personally feel it's good value for money. Would recommend setting up a call with their team if you're doubtful about whether or not the product will be useful for you. They are a really honest bunch of folks and I appreciate it so much.

      Anuva Agarwal • May 18, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Really good with applying jobs

      I think they provide good assistance to apply jobs and I did get some positive responses after that. hence, I am quite satisfied with the experience of scale.jobs. There cover letters....

      Neha Sawant • March 21, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Superb service!

      Great team of people and the person that was assigned to work with me was wonderful too. Majority of the heavy lifting is done by them and they are in constant communication with you....

      Adnan Lakdawala • July 01, 2023
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Drastically reducing the burden!

      Apply at scale has immensely helped me with my tedious job application process. Their team is proactive and smart. Once they understand your profile, they are good at applying.......

      Mihika Srivastava • December 01, 2023
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      They took away the work I was slacking…

      They took away the work I was slacking on, which allowed me to relax and not worry about submitting my applications. I was on an extremely busy schedule.

      Harish Reddy Kondapalli • January 29, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great for international students

      Scale.jobs has been an excellent help in applying for high volume of jobs which otherwise would be very time consuming. This is extremely useful in the current job market as a high-volume approach helped me get few interview calls which I wasn't getting earlier. Also, they keep bringing in new features such as the networking tool. Excited to try it out!

      Shobhit Datta • May 31, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Great service to save time while interviewing

      Great service to save time while interviewing. I have been using it for a week. The support is nice and turnaround is within 24 hours. Price point maybe on the expensive side, but you pay for the time it saves to create accounts on several sites and apply jobs.

      Hemil P • May 20, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      extremely helpful in this challenging…

      I've been using Scale.jobs, and it has been an incredibly useful tool for my job search. The platform's intuitive design and user-friendly interface make it easy to navigate through various job listings. I appreciate the detailed job descriptions and the ability to filter positions based on my preferences. The application process is streamlined, saving me a lot of time. Overall, Scale.jobs has significantly enhanced my job search experience, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for new opportunities.

      Avinash Amudala • May 28, 2024
      via Trustpilot
    • 5 stars

      Good service to save some time from job applications

      So far, my experience has been positive. I have been using their service for 2 months and am looking forward to continuing.

      Hari Vilas • May 19, 2024
      via Trustpilot

    300+ people landed their dream jobs in a stress-free process by smartly delegating.

    Landed fulltime roles in 3 months

    47% from our applications, 44% from personal networking and individual efforts.

    Less time spent in job search

    We reduce the average 5 months job search to 1-3 months.

    Return on Investment

    Saved weeks mean an extra $20K, plus multiple offers often lead to a $30K salary increase.

    Our skilled Assistants are ready to supercharge your job search. Hire your dedicated assistant and start delegating your applications.

    Arjun Gupta

    Arjun Gupta

    Sophomore at IIT Bombay

    Star5.0 (17 reviews)
    2560+ applications

    It is personally gratifying to see my clients landing in their full time after a long hustle

    Kanika Joshi

    Kanika Joshi

    Junior Year at VIT University

    Star4.9 (36 reviews)
    6542+ applications

    Experiencing the moment when clients achieve their goal brings a profound sense of personal satisfaction.

    Abhishek Verma

    Abhishek Verma

    Senior Year at Anna University

    Star4.8 (24 reviews)
    2548+ applications

    I found a job for a client in 2 weeks. It was a great feeling

    Priyanka Pandya

    Priyanka Pandya

    Sophomore at PSG College

    Star4.9 (27 reviews)
    9875+ applications

    The joy of assisting clients in their pursuit of a full-time career is unparalleled

    Karthik Reddy

    Karthik Reddy

    Senior Year at Jadavpur Univ.

    Star5.0 (19 reviews)
    4547+ applications

    There's a unique sense of fulfillment in helping clients navigate the job market

    Shreya Singh

    Shreya Singh

    Junior Year at TISS, Mumbai

    Star4.8 (42 reviews)
    1548+ applications

    Helping clients land a job is a rewarding experience

    Monica de Souza

    Monica de Souza

    Senior Year at VJTI, Mumbai

    Star4.9 (28 reviews)
    895+ applications

    Being a wingman to my clients became my favorite part of my day, I love it.

    Rahul Shetty

    Rahul Shetty

    Sophomore at Christ University

    Star5.0 (12 reviews)
    4789+ applications

    My best moment was when a client called me to tell that she landed a job. I was the second one she called to.

    See how our assistants can make a difference in your job search.

    Man
    Pinch to zoom in

    Our assistants provide personalized support, helping you delegate the grunt work of job applications with efficiency and ease.

    95% of questions are answered here. Can't find what you're looking for? Feel free to reach out!

    Have more questions? Let's chat!

    We understand that you might have questions specific to your situation. Schedule a call with our founder – we're here to help you succeed!

    Flexible scheduling
    One-on-one call
    Personalized advice

    Limited slots available. Book your call now!

    Our platform is backed by leading experts in careers, immigration, and personal growth. Their support validates our commitment to your success.

    Pritesh Jagani (Yudi J)

    Pritesh Jagani (Yudi J)

    400K+ followers

    Career Development Expert

    Helped 10,000+ professionals accelerate their careers through strategic guidance.

    Melissa Grabiner

    Melissa Grabiner

    387K+ followers

    #1 HR LinkedIn Creator in US

    Job Search Coach and Talent Acquisition Director with 20 years of experience.

    Harnoor Singh (Singh in USA)

    Harnoor Singh (Singh in USA)

    1.3M+ followers

    Immigration Insights Leader

    Demystified US immigration for over 1 million aspiring professionals.

    Linda Le

    Linda Le

    584K+ followers

    Job Hunt and LinkedIn Expert

    Co-founder of CWI and expert in helping jobseekers land jobs.

    Soundarya Balasubramani

    Soundarya Balasubramani

    150K+ followers

    Talent Visas Expert

    Author of 'Admitted', guiding countless students to top global universities.

    Will McTighe

    Will McTighe

    192K+ followers

    Career Expert & Stanford MBA

    Advises on career obstacles and writes a newsletter covering job strategies.

    Sanjeev Sriram

    Sanjeev Sriram

    150K+ followers

    Master's Abroad Expert

    Provided Insights and Everything About Pursuing Master's Abroad.

    Priya Bajaj (Its Ok Yaar)

    Priya Bajaj (Its Ok Yaar)

    80K+ followers

    Desi Immigrant Influencer

    Influencer sharing relatable life abroad experiences and immigrant advice.

    April Little

    April Little

    250K+ followers

    Leadership & Executive Coach

    Empowering professionals and women leaders to reach new heights.

    Pritesh Jagani (Yudi J)

    Pritesh Jagani (Yudi J)

    400K+ followers

    Career Development Expert

    Helped 10,000+ professionals accelerate their careers through strategic guidance.

    Melissa Grabiner

    Melissa Grabiner

    387K+ followers

    #1 HR LinkedIn Creator in US

    Job Search Coach and Talent Acquisition Director with 20 years of experience.

    Harnoor Singh (Singh in USA)

    Harnoor Singh (Singh in USA)

    1.3M+ followers

    Immigration Insights Leader

    Demystified US immigration for over 1 million aspiring professionals.

    Linda Le

    Linda Le

    584K+ followers

    Job Hunt and LinkedIn Expert

    Co-founder of CWI and expert in helping jobseekers land jobs.

    Soundarya Balasubramani

    Soundarya Balasubramani

    150K+ followers

    Talent Visas Expert

    Author of 'Admitted', guiding countless students to top global universities.

    Will McTighe

    Will McTighe

    192K+ followers

    Career Expert & Stanford MBA

    Advises on career obstacles and writes a newsletter covering job strategies.

    Sanjeev Sriram

    Sanjeev Sriram

    150K+ followers

    Master's Abroad Expert

    Provided Insights and Everything About Pursuing Master's Abroad.

    Priya Bajaj (Its Ok Yaar)

    Priya Bajaj (Its Ok Yaar)

    80K+ followers

    Desi Immigrant Influencer

    Influencer sharing relatable life abroad experiences and immigrant advice.

    April Little

    April Little

    250K+ followers

    Leadership & Executive Coach

    Empowering professionals and women leaders to reach new heights.

    I hope this letter finds you well, though I understand if it doesn't. The current job market, especially in the US, is tough. I've been there – a recent graduate from Carnegie Mellon, suddenly laid off and thrust into one of the most stressful phases of my life.

    We're told that the key to landing a job is networking and applying to hundreds of positions. But let's be honest: endlessly typing the same information into countless applications is soul-crushing. And the silence that follows? Even more so. With a 98% non-response rate, it's a wonder any of us can stay motivated.

    I tried everything – auto-filling extensions, AI services, you name it. Nothing worked. In desperation, I hired a college student from India and trained them to apply on my behalf. The result? I landed a job in just 60 days.

    This experience was a revelation. I realized that while we can't change the system, we can be smarter in how we navigate it. That's why I started this service – to help others like us escape the job hunt trauma.

    We're not just another job application service. We're a team that understands your struggles firsthand. We're here to take the burden off your shoulders, so you can focus on what truly matters – preparing for interviews and building meaningful connections.

    If you're feeling overwhelmed, know that you're not alone. And more importantly, know that there's hope. Let us help you regain control of your job search and your future.

    Wishing you the very best in your journey,

    Leela Yanamaddi's Signature

    Leela Yanamaddi

    Co-Founder

    A laid off Carnegie Mellon Grad

    LinkedIn Profile

    Ready to transform your job search?