Looking for a job but not sure which service to use? Here's a breakdown of two popular options: Kelly Services and scale.jobs, each offering a completely different approach to job searching.

• Kelly Services: A recruiter-driven staffing agency that connects you to exclusive roles, often with Fortune 100 companies. They specialize in fields like science, healthcare, IT, and education. However, you're dependent on their network and client demand, with less control over your job search.
• scale.jobs: A hands-on service where human assistants directly apply for jobs on your behalf. You choose the roles, and they handle the applications, including creating tailored resumes and cover letters. With clear, upfront pricing (starting at $199 for 250 applications), you get full control, transparency, and fast results.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Kelly Services	scale.jobs
Who Pays	Employers	Job seekers
Application Method	Recruiter-submitted	Human assistants manually apply
Customization	Generic profiles reused	Tailored resumes and cover letters
Cost	Free for job seekers (employer-funded)	Starts at $199 for 250 applications
Control	Limited (recruiter-driven)	Full control over jobs and timeline
Updates	Through recruiters	Real-time WhatsApp updates with proof

If you want exclusive access to high-level roles and don't mind waiting on recruiters, Kelly Services might work for you. But if you need speed, transparency, and control, scale.jobs is the better choice for most job seekers.

Voice of Talent | Kelly Services

What Kelly Services Offers Job Seekers

Kelly Services functions as a traditional staffing agency, focusing on matching candidates to roles based on employer needs rather than individual preferences. This approach differs from direct application methods, so it's essential to assess if this more passive job search strategy aligns with your career goals.

Staffing Agency Model

With over 1,000 recruiters, Kelly Services connects job seekers to temporary, temp-to-perm, and direct-hire positions. They work with 91 of the world's top 100 brands, giving candidates access to job openings that often aren't publicly advertised.

When you upload your resume to Kelly's career site, recruiters evaluate your qualifications and pair you with roles that match their clients' current demands. However, the timing and availability of these opportunities depend entirely on the hiring needs of their clients, not the job seeker's personal timeline.

Kelly Services places candidates across various industries, with specialized divisions like Science & Clinical offering high-paying roles for professionals with advanced degrees. In addition to job placement, they provide support services such as interview coaching and follow-ups. You can also join their Talent Community, which allows recruiters to continually access your credentials. However, even with these resources, job seekers remain in a passive position, relying on recruiters to drive the process.

In addition to recruiter assistance, Kelly Services incorporates digital tools designed primarily to meet employer needs.

Digital Tools and Employer Services

Kelly Services leverages digital systems to streamline the hiring process for employers. These tools are built to optimize employer workflows, focusing on their priorities. However, this means job seekers have limited options to track or manage their applications, reinforcing the passive nature of the staffing model.

While these digital tools help employers, the cost structure also shapes the candidate experience.

Cost Structure and User Experience

Job seekers can use Kelly Services for free, as employers cover all associated fees. While this eliminates upfront costs, the experience can feel unpredictable. Job opportunities and timelines are entirely dictated by client demand, leaving candidates with less control over their job search process.

Reviews for Kelly Services are mixed. Some candidates appreciate the access to exclusive opportunities, while others express frustration with the lack of control and the variable timelines. Since employers are the paying clients, they naturally receive more attention, which can leave job seekers feeling secondary in the process.

This model works well for individuals who are comfortable with a passive approach to job hunting. However, it may not suit those who prefer to actively manage their applications and target specific roles or companies.

How scale.jobs Direct Applications Work

Scale.jobs gives you the tools to apply directly for jobs, combining software, AI, and human expertise to support your efforts. Unlike the less predictable recruiter-driven approach of services like Kelly Services, scale.jobs puts you in control. You set the pace and priorities, while still benefiting from professional assistance to boost your chances of landing the job you want. Here's a closer look at how their service tiers and tracking system make job applications faster and more efficient.

3-Tier Service Structure

Scale.jobs offers three service levels to suit different budgets and job search needs:

• Free Tier: Includes basic job board access, an ATS-friendly resume builder, and limited AI support.
• AI Assistant Pro: For $9/month, this tier removes daily limits and enables unlimited resume creation.
• Human Assistant: Starting at $199 for 250 applications, this premium option includes trained human assistants who manually submit applications. Each submission features ATS-optimized resumes and personalized cover letters tailored to the role. Additional services, like LinkedIn profile optimization or dedicated recruiters, are available for higher-volume campaigns.

The Human Assistant service is the platform’s standout offering, providing a hands-on approach to help you apply effectively for each opportunity.

Application Tracking and Documentation

Scale.jobs takes tracking seriously, ensuring transparency and accountability for every application. Submissions come with time-stamped WhatsApp notifications and a centralized log that serves as proof-of-work. If you don’t use all your credits, they’re either refunded or rolled over into future campaigns.

Weekly updates summarize your progress, including the total number of applications submitted, response rates, and recommendations for adjustments. If a job closes before submission or duplicate applications are flagged, the credit isn’t deducted from your total.

Flat-Fee Pricing Structure

Scale.jobs uses a straightforward, one-time payment model with no hidden fees or recurring subscriptions. For example, a $199 campaign covers 250 applications, and you can pause, adjust, or speed up your campaign without extra charges.

Typically, a 250-application campaign is completed within 2–3 weeks. However, if you’re targeting fast-paced fields like customer success or technical support, you can opt for an expedited schedule, completing the same volume in just 1–1.5 weeks by increasing daily submissions.

Kelly Services vs. scale.jobs: Side-by-Side Comparison

Let’s take a closer look at how Kelly Services and scale.jobs differ in their approach to serving users, managing application volumes, pricing, and the tools they offer. These two services operate on entirely different models, catering to distinct audiences with unique needs and timelines.

Target Users and Service Focus

Kelly Services primarily caters to employers, offering staffing, outsourcing, and workforce management solutions. As a job seeker using Kelly, you’re part of their employer-driven placement system, not a direct paying customer. They specialize in industries like science, engineering, education, healthcare, and IT, leveraging decades of recruiting expertise to fill client roles.

On the flip side, scale.jobs is all about empowering individual job seekers. You pay a flat fee upfront and receive a guaranteed number of applications within a set timeframe. Along with this, you get ATS-optimized resumes and real-time tracking, giving you full control over your job search instead of waiting for a recruiter to match you with opportunities.

The key difference? Kelly focuses on meeting employer needs and securing successful placements, while scale.jobs prioritizes maximizing your application volume and ensuring your documents are polished and job-ready. This distinction shapes how each handles application timelines and outcomes.

Application Volume and Timeline Control

With Kelly Services, your application activity depends on recruiters finding opportunities that match your profile within their client network. There’s no guarantee on the number of applications or the timing. One week you might see several opportunities, while another week could be completely quiet, depending on client demand and recruiter availability in your area.

In contrast, scale.jobs offers clear volume guarantees with set timelines. For example, their $199 Basic plan promises 250 applications completed in 2–3 weeks, while expedited campaigns for fast-paced roles like customer support can deliver the same volume in just 1–1.5 weeks. Weekly updates keep you informed with progress summaries, response rates, and actionable recommendations.

This difference matters if you’re working against tight deadlines, like visa requirements, or if you’re unemployed and need to maximize interview opportunities quickly.

Pricing and Cost Transparency

Kelly Services doesn’t charge job seekers directly since employers fund their staffing and outsourcing engagements. While job postings may show pay rates (e.g., $28–$32/hour for a scientist role in Boston), there’s no public pricing for their services, as these are tailored for businesses.

Scale.jobs, however, uses a straightforward pricing model with fixed tiers. Their Basic plan costs $199, which breaks down to roughly $0.80 per application, making it easy to calculate your cost per opportunity. If you don’t use all your credits, they’re either refunded or rolled over into future campaigns, ensuring transparency and flexibility.

Service	Who Pays	Pricing Model	Cost Transparency
Kelly Services	Employers	Quote-based for clients	Pay rates visible on job postings
scale.jobs	Job seekers	Fixed pricing tiers	$0.80 per application (Basic plan)

Next, let’s examine how their tools and document optimization further set these services apart.

Available Tools and Document Optimization

Kelly Services prioritizes tools that benefit employers and recruiters. Their platforms, like Helix, focus on workforce management and performance tracking. While the Kelly Now app allows candidates to apply and manage communications, most of their tech is designed to enhance employer efficiency rather than improve the individual job seeker experience.

Scale.jobs, on the other hand, offers tools tailored specifically for job seekers. These include resume builders, job trackers, and personalized workflows for each application. Their Human Assistant service creates custom resumes and cover letters optimized for specific job descriptions, ensuring alignment with keywords and required skills.

This difference highlights the focus of each service. Kelly’s tools are built for managing large-scale workforce needs, while scale.jobs is designed to give individual job seekers the resources they need to succeed in their job search. It’s a clear reflection of their respective priorities: employer outcomes for Kelly and job seeker success for scale.jobs.

Why scale.jobs Works Better for Most Job Seekers

Scale.jobs offers distinct advantages for job seekers navigating today’s competitive job market. Unlike Kelly Services, which primarily focuses on employer-driven solutions and managed workforce services, scale.jobs empowers job seekers with greater control, transparency, and personalized support. This approach leads to a more effective and tailored job search experience.

Manual Application Submissions

At scale.jobs, every application is submitted manually by trained human assistants, ensuring a personal touch that automated systems often lack. Many platforms, including Kelly Services, rely on recruiter-driven pipelines or internal systems designed to serve their employer clients. When Kelly submits your profile, it’s processed through their managed workforce platform, which limits your opportunities to roles within their client network.

Scale.jobs takes a different approach. Their human assistants handle applications on any portal - whether it’s Workday, Greenhouse, or a company’s direct site. They manage all the intricate details, from filling out specific form fields to uploading required documents and answering unique questions. You’ll receive timestamped screenshots of completed applications, confirmation numbers, and a tracker that shows exactly where your resume has been sent.

Custom Documents for Each Application

Scale.jobs stands out with its 24-hour turnaround for creating personalized, ATS-optimized resumes and cover letters. These documents are tailored to match specific job keywords and required skills, significantly increasing your chances of passing applicant tracking systems. Staffing agencies like Kelly Services, however, often reuse generic candidate profiles across multiple client roles to save time. While efficient for their business model, this method may not highlight your unique qualifications for each job.

This fast and tailored approach is especially beneficial for job seekers targeting diverse roles. In a competitive market, having a customized resume ready within 24 hours can be the difference between getting noticed and being overlooked.

One-Time Payment Model

Another key advantage of scale.jobs is its straightforward pricing. They charge a one-time flat fee, free of hidden costs, recurring subscriptions, or unexpected charges, making it easy to budget for your job search. By contrast, Kelly Services operates on an employer-funded model, meaning their focus remains on meeting employer needs rather than optimizing the individual job seeker’s experience.

With scale.jobs, you know exactly what you’re paying upfront. Unused application credits can either be refunded or rolled over for future use, offering flexibility and peace of mind. This pricing model is particularly helpful for those facing urgent deadlines, such as visa constraints or unemployment periods.

Direct Communication and Support

Scale.jobs takes transparency and communication to the next level. Through real-time WhatsApp updates, live application tracking, and proof-of-work screenshots, you’re kept in the loop every step of the way. You’ll know immediately when applications are submitted and can monitor your progress through a centralized dashboard. In contrast, Kelly Services typically communicates through recruiters, focusing on employer outcomes, which can result in slower updates and less detailed feedback for candidates.

The scale.jobs dashboard also tracks the status of your applications, helping you stay organized and enabling strategic follow-ups. This direct support model aligns their success with yours - when you land interviews and offers, they succeed too. It’s a partnership designed to prioritize your goals.

Feature	Kelly Services	scale.jobs
Application Method	Recruiter-submitted through internal systems	Human assistants manually submit to any portal
Document Customization	Generic profiles reused across roles	24-hour tailored resumes/cover letters for each job
Pricing Model	Employer-funded (no direct cost)	Flat fee with clear per-application costs
Communication	Through recruiters, as available	Real-time WhatsApp updates with proof-of-work
Application Volume	Limited to agency’s client network	Broad access to any job portal

These features make scale.jobs an excellent choice for job seekers who value control, speed, and transparency in their search. Instead of waiting for agency-managed roles that may not align with your goals, scale.jobs gives you the tools to take charge of your career path.

When Kelly Services Might Work for You

While scale.jobs offers greater control and transparency for most job seekers, there are certain scenarios where Kelly Services stands out. Its long-standing relationships with clients and specialized industry knowledge can give candidates a unique edge. Kelly Services is particularly suited for those in niche industries, but it may not be the best fit for individuals needing fast, high-volume applications. Knowing when to use Kelly Services - and understanding its limitations - can help you choose the right job search strategy.

Best Use Cases for Kelly Services

Kelly Services shines in specific areas, particularly for roles in education and paraprofessional positions. Thanks to its strong connections with school districts and educational institutions, it provides direct access to jobs like substitute teaching, administrative support, and paraprofessional roles - often ones that aren’t widely advertised.

If you’re looking for temp-to-hire opportunities, Kelly Services can also be a great resource. Their established relationships with employers often mean they hear about permanent positions before they’re made public. This can help qualified candidates transition quickly into full-time roles.

Another area where they excel is manufacturing and production staffing. Whether you’re targeting jobs in warehousing, assembly, quality control, or production supervision, Kelly Services’ strong industry ties can lead to quicker placements compared to applying on your own.

For those who prefer less involvement in the application process, Kelly Services is a good choice. If you’re currently working or find the job search process overwhelming, their recruiters can handle initial screenings and applications for you, saving time and effort.

However, it’s important to weigh these benefits against the limitations that come with using a staffing agency.

Kelly Services Limitations

Despite its strengths, Kelly Services has some notable drawbacks. One major limitation is its reliance on client demand. Unlike scale.jobs, which can apply to a wide range of positions across industries, Kelly Services only offers roles from its own client network. This means you could miss out on opportunities at companies that don’t work with staffing agencies or prefer direct hiring.

Another challenge is the unpredictable application timeline. While scale.jobs guarantees a 24-hour turnaround on custom documents and immediate application submissions, Kelly Services operates on recruiter availability and client needs. This can lead to delays - sometimes weeks - before suitable opportunities arise, or you might lose out on leads as client priorities shift.

The volume of opportunities can also vary. Since your prospects depend entirely on the agency’s network, slower periods could leave you with few or no job options.

Additionally, there’s limited job targeting. Kelly Services only presents roles from its existing client base, which means you won’t have the flexibility to pursue specific companies or positions you’ve identified through your own research or networking.

Lastly, the agency’s employer-focused model can sometimes create conflicts of interest. Since Kelly Services earns its revenue from employers, there’s a risk they might prioritize roles that strengthen their client relationships over ones that align perfectly with your career goals.

Limitation	Impact on Job Seekers	scale.jobs Alternative
Client-only opportunities	Miss out on jobs outside the agency’s network	Broader job search coverage
No application guarantees	Uncertain volume of opportunities	Fixed packages with refund options
Recruiter-dependent timing	Delays based on recruiter availability	24-hour custom document turnaround
Limited job targeting	Can’t pursue specific dream roles	Full control over job selection

These limitations make Kelly Services a better fit for job seekers with flexible timelines, a focus on specific industries, or those who prioritize convenience over control. For professionals seeking a more comprehensive job search approach with guaranteed activity and transparent processes, scale.jobs offers a stronger alternative.

Kelly Services or scale.jobs: Decision Guide

Based on the comparisons above, here's a guide to help you decide between Kelly Services' recruiter-driven placements and scale.jobs' transparent, hands-on application process. The choice depends on how you prefer to manage your job search.

Go with Kelly Services if:

• You want recruiters to handle the screening and submission process for you.
• You’re okay with an unpredictable flow of job opportunities.
• You like the traditional staffing agency approach, even though pricing details aren't publicly shared.

Opt for scale.jobs if:

• You prefer guaranteed application volumes with clear, flat-rate pricing. Packages range from $199 for 250 applications to $399 for 1,000, and any unused credits are refunded.
• Speed and consistency are priorities, with 24-hour resume turnarounds and immediate submissions.
• You’re looking for broader market coverage, applying to roles across multiple industries instead of being limited to one agency's network.
• Transparency and control matter to you, with features like real-time WhatsApp updates, time-stamped proof-of-work screenshots, and detailed tracking of your applications.

Decision Factor	Kelly Services	scale.jobs
Best for Roles	Traditional staffing placements	All industries and job levels
Application Timeline	Unpredictable, recruiter-dependent	24-hour guaranteed turnaround
Pricing Transparency	Employer-funded, undisclosed pricing	Clear one-time fees ($199–$399)
Job Search Control	Limited to agency-client network	Broad market access and precise targeting
Application Volume	Variable based on client demand	Guaranteed package delivery

Whether you prefer a recruiter-led approach or want full control with broad market access, this guide can help you pick the service that aligns with your goals.

FAQs

How do Kelly Services and scale.jobs differ when it comes to job search control and transparency?

Kelly Services follows a more traditional staffing model, which typically involves placement fees and gives job seekers limited involvement in the application process. On the other hand, scale.jobs takes a modern, hands-on approach that prioritizes clarity and involvement. Their features include ATS-optimized documents, proof-of-work visibility, and dedicated WhatsApp support, ensuring job seekers remain informed and engaged every step of the way.

For those who prefer greater involvement in their job search and a clear understanding of the efforts being made on their behalf, scale.jobs provides a refreshing alternative to the conventional methods used by Kelly Services.

How does scale.jobs’ pricing compare to Kelly Services’ employer-funded model for job seekers?

Scale.jobs takes a straightforward approach with its one-time payment model, offering job seekers a clear and transparent value. This means no recurring subscription fees and access to perks like human-powered assistance, ATS-optimized documents, and real-time WhatsApp support. By paying upfront, you know exactly what you're getting - no surprises, no extra costs.

On the other hand, Kelly Services operates on an employer-funded model, where companies cover the costs of staffing services. While this setup can lower out-of-pocket expenses for job seekers, it often prioritizes the needs of employers over individual candidates. This can mean less personalized guidance and reduced clarity for job seekers. With Scale.jobs, the pricing is simple and upfront, ensuring tailored support without hidden fees or compromises.

When is Kelly Services a better choice than scale.jobs for specialized roles?

When it comes to hiring for highly specialized or technical fields - like STEM industries or niche markets - Kelly Services often stands out as a stronger option compared to scale.jobs. Their ability to quickly assemble skilled teams and tackle complex hiring challenges makes them a go-to choice for roles that demand specific qualifications or expertise.

This can be especially valuable in competitive markets where the demand for specialized talent is intense. If you're aiming to secure candidates with unique skills or need to rapidly expand a team for technical projects, Kelly Services could provide the advantage you're looking for.

Related posts

• Is Robert Half Worth Using? Scale Jobs Staffing Alternative